Home > Business > PTI > Report

US media slams developed nations over WTO talks collapse

September 16, 2003 19:26 IST

The United States' media on Tuesday lashed out at the developed countries for their 'callous indifference' to the demands of the poor nations which led to the collapse of WTO talks in Cancun.

"The rich world, including the United States, Europe and Japan, should be faulted for not offering a more generous agricultural deal at an earlier date," the Washington Post said.

Also Read


Cancun 2003: Complete Coverage

India and the WTO: Complete Coverage


However, it said, "middle income countries such as Brazil, India and China played a more pernicious role by joining much poorer countries in a bloc, claiming to share their interests and inveighing against a deal."

"There is, in short, a lot of hypocrisy all around the WTO at the moment," the paper said.

Blaming the rich nations for derailing the talks, The New York Times mentioned that Cancun meant 'snake pit' in the local language.

It said the developed world, including the US which it accused of a 'muted response,' had sent a 'crushing message' of 'callous indifference.'

It said the US, Japan along with European Union formed the 'coalition of the unwilling' that gave the meeting 'an unfortunate north-versus-south cast.'

The Washington Times said the collapse of Cancun talks was 'a failure of US trade diplomacy.'

"It is also the latest evidence of a change in the free-trade ethos around the world, which surged in the decades after World War II, but has become increasingly questioned in the last several years," the paper said.

The divide between Europe and poor countries was evident long before the Cancun meeting, The Washington Times said, adding: "America, as the leader of the free world and primary advocate of free trade, failed to induce an agreement."

"What really died on Sunday was the developed world illusion, especially in Europe, that farm subsidies are untouchable," the Wall Street Journal said.

The failure of the World Trade Organisation talks 'will yet lead to progress if this farm lesson is driven home to those parts of the European, American and Japanese economies that depend on expanding global markets.'

"Farmers account for just five percent of the European Union's population, and a mere two percent of its GDP, yet agriculture has been wagging EU trade policy for years," the Journal said.


Article Tools

Email this Article

Printer-Friendly Format

Letter to the Editor




Related Stories


India, China join on investment

SJM maha dharna on Sept 2

WTO readies for agri battle



People Who Read This Also Read


Cancun:India has nothing to show

SC halts HPCL, BPCL sell-off

Cancun collapse, victory for us






© Copyright 2003 PTI. All rights reserved. Republication or redistribution of PTI content, including by framing or similar means, is expressly prohibited without the prior written consent.











Copyright © 2003 rediff.com India Limited. All Rights Reserved.