HOME   
   NEWS   
   BUSINESS   
   CRICKET   
   SPORTS   
   MOVIES   
   NET GUIDE   
   SHOPPING   
   BLOGS  
   ASTROLOGY  
   MATCHMAKER  


Search:



The Web

Rediff








News
Capital Buzz
Commentary
Dear Rediff
Diary
Elections
Interviews
Rediff Poll
Specials
Gallery
The States



Home > News > PTI

'India in place of France in United Nations
Security Council'


February 10, 2003 01:11 IST

India should replace France as a permanent member of the United Nations Security Council, senior columnist Thomas L Friedman of the The New York Times said.

He said that Paris was so caught up with its need to differentiate itself from Washington to feel important that it has become 'silly'.

India is the world's biggest democracy, the world's biggest Hindu nation and the world's second largest Muslim nation and, 'quite frankly, India is just so much more serious these days,' Friedman wrote in his column.

India, he said, may be ambivalent about war in Iraq, but it does so honestly. But France is not able to see how the world has changed since the end of the cold war. India can, he said.

Throughout the cold war, Friedman said, France sought to differentiate itself by playing between the Soviet and American blocs. France could get away with this 'entertaining little game' for two reasons:  First, it knew that Uncle Sam, in the end, would always protect it from the Soviet bear. "So France could tweak America's beak, do business with Iraq and enjoy America's military protection."

And second, the cold war world was a much more stable place, Friedman said. Despite the world being divided between two nuclear superpowers, both were status quo powers in their own ways. "They represented different orders, but they both represented order," he said.              

Today's world is also divided, but it is increasingly divided between a 'World of Order' ---- anchored by America, the European Union, Russia, India, China and Japan, and joined by scores of smaller nations --- and the 'World of Disorder', said Friedman.

The World of Disorder, is dominated by rogue regimes like Iraq's and North Korea's and various global terror networks stretching from the Middle East to Indonesia, he said.

"There is room for disagreement. There is no room for a lack of seriousness. And the whole French game on Iraq, spearheaded by its diplomacy --- like foreign minister Dominique de Villepin, lacks seriousness.

"The inspections have not worked yet, says de Villepin, because Saddam has not fully cooperated, and, therefore, we should triple the number of inspectors. But the inspections have failed not because of a shortage of inspectors. They have failed because of a shortage of compliance on Saddam's part, as the French know, wrote Friedman.

In a strong attack on the French position, he said, "De Villepin also suggested that Saddam's government pass a legislation to prohibit the manufacture of weapons of mass destruction. That proposal alone is a reminder of why, if America didn't exist and Europe had to rely on France, most Europeans today would be speaking either German or Russian."

If France were serious about its own position, it would join US in setting a deadline for Iraq to comply, he said.

"And France would send its prime minister to Iraq to tell that directly to Saddam. Oh, France's prime minister was on the road last week.  He was out drumming up business for French companies in the world's biggest emerging computer society. He was in India," he said.



© Copyright 2003 PTI. All rights reserved. Republication or redistribution of PTI content, including by framing or similar means, is expressly prohibited without the prior written consent.






Article Tools

Email this Article

Printer-Friendly Format

Letter to the Editor



Related Stories


War should be last resort: France

Kuwait to immunise defence forces

J G Nadkarni: The Nuclear Threat








HOME   
   NEWS   
   BUSINESS   
   CRICKET   
   SPORTS   
   MOVIES   
   NET GUIDE   
   SHOPPING   
   BLOGS  
   ASTROLOGY  
   MATCHMAKER  
Copyright © 2003 rediff.com India Limited. All Rights Reserved.